Fear Dressed Up As Practicality

'I'm just being practical.'

'I don't want to rock the boat.'

'I just need a little more information.'

'I'd feel guilty saying no.'

Every one of those statements sounds like good judgment. Sometimes it is.

Other times, it's fear in a very convincing disguise.

Fear is a protective state. It's vigilant, it's future-focused, and it asks 'what could go wrong?'. It usually got its job for a good reason. It just never got the memo that the danger passed. (I wrote about the two forces behind most decisions back in February, if you want to read more about that.)

The details change from client to client, but the pattern rarely does.

It can look like a personal rule: if anyone asks for help, the answer is yes. It reads as generosity, and often it is. But when we look underneath, it can be about control. If you're always the one giving, you're never the one who has to ask, or wait, or hear 'no.' You set the terms. You stay put together and sought after. You hold the power, so you can't be let down, and you never have to be on the receiving end of anything. The rule isn't really about the other person. It's about staying safe.

It's also exhausting. When everyone wants a piece of you, you end up depleted.

It can look like an identity: 'I don't quit.' That one gets applauded, and it can be a real strength. It can also keep you in commitments that stopped bringing you joy, fulfillment, and/or value a long time ago, because leaving would mean facing who you are if you're not the one who stays. Sometimes the shift is as small as changing one word: 'quit' becomes 'edit.'

It can also look like a mind that goes to 'failure' in a hurry when money gets tight, then pushes for a decision, any decision, that will make the discomfort stop. Fear reads instability as danger. One person discovered they actually felt safest in the messy middle they'd been trying so hard to escape.

None of it is irrational. All of it is protection. And once you can see the disguise, you can feel the difference between a choice that's yours and one fear is making for you.

Here are a few of the disguises I see most:

'Practical.' The list of what could go wrong is much longer than the list of what you want.

'Helpful.' Saying yes to everyone who asks, because being the one who gives keeps you in control.

'Patient.' Waiting for one more data point when part of you already knows.

'Decisive.' The flip side: rushing to a choice to escape the discomfort of not knowing.

'Loyal.' Staying because of everything you've already put in, not because you'd choose it again today.

The tell is usually the same: the relief shows up quickly. The cost shows up slowly, in the options you quietly stop considering.

Possibility-led decisions aren't reckless. They ask 'what could go right? What's true here? What do I trust?' And sometimes the answer is still 'stay' or 'wait.' The difference is that you're choosing it instead of hiding in it.

Try this on the decision you've been circling. Finish both sentences: 'Choosing this protects me from ____.' 'Choosing this moves me toward ____.'

If the first one fills in faster, that's information, not a verdict.

Questions for you to consider:

  • Which decision am I calling 'practical' that might really be fear?

  • Where am I saying yes to avoid the discomfort of a no?

  • What am I waiting for permission to do, even though I already know the answer?

  • If I removed fear, what would I choose?

To choosing possibility, Darrah

Next
Next

The Gift Of Another Year